Why Climate Disclosure Is Becoming a Finance Function

An emissions figure can travel farther than the team that produced it expects. Once filed, it can enter a customer's procurement assessment, an investor's analysis, or a board's review of operating performance. The company then has to explain where the number came from, what it includes, and who reviewed it.
Two dates sit one day apart. COP31 opens November 9 in Antalya, Türkiye, and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change lists the UN Climate Change Conference - Antalya, November 2026 as running through November 20. On Tuesday, November 10, the first emissions reports under California's SB 253 come due. Both draw strong opinions, and this article sets them aside. Whatever your view of the policy, a company that files an emissions figure with a state regulator has published a number. Published numbers need owners, controls, and reviewers. Finance already works that way, and climate disclosure now falls inside that discipline whether or not anyone budgeted for it.
What California Requires in the First Reports
On October 12, the California Office of Administrative Law approved the initial regulation from the California Air Resources Board (CARB), and it took effect that day, according to the CARB notice California Corporate Greenhouse Gas Reporting. The notice sets November 10 as the first-year deadline and describes covered companies as U.S.-based entities with annual revenues above $1 billion that do business in California. Coverage is an entity-level call, and the CARB California Corporate Greenhouse Gas Reporting: Guidance for SB 253 2026 Reporting Submittals makes the company responsible for making it.
First-year reports cover Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions. Scope 1 means direct emissions from sources a company owns or controls. Scope 2 means indirect emissions from the energy it buys, such as electricity. Scope 3, which reaches across the value chain, begins in 2027.
The first filing comes with flexibility. In the guidance, CARB says it will use enforcement discretion for this report. Companies may submit Scope 1 and Scope 2 figures for their prior fiscal year based on information they already had, or were collecting, when the agency issued its December 2024 enforcement notice, whether or not that data received limited assurance. A company that wasn't collecting emissions data then is asked to send a statement of non-reporting on company letterhead. White & Case, in California climate disclosure laws: CARB releases optional intake platform and guidance for 2026 reporting, notes that reports and statements submitted through the optional CARB intake platform will be made public. Even a statement of non-reporting is a formal representation, and someone has to be able to support it.
The statute also carries penalty authority. Greenberg Traurig, in California SB 253: CARB Sets Nov. 10, 2026, Deadline for Scope 1 and Scope 2 Emissions Reports, notes that SB 253 authorizes administrative penalties of up to $500,000 in a reporting year and that CARB will exercise enforcement discretion in the first year. Flexibility around a first filing doesn't show that the process behind it is dependable.
The companion law, SB 261, stands apart. It covers climate-related financial risk reports. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has enjoined its enforcement pending appeal, and CARB has said it won't enforce SB 261 while the injunction remains, according to the Morgan Lewis LawFlash California's Climate Disclosure Regulations Receive Final Approval Ahead of November Reporting Deadline. The injunction doesn't extend to SB 253.
Why Climate Disclosure Data Needs a Finance Owner
In many companies, emissions data starts outside finance. It comes from facilities, operations, procurement, or a sustainability team, built from fuel purchases, utility invoices, and meter readings. That arrangement holds up until the number leaves the building. After a filing, the questions change. Who approved it? Which records support it? What moved since the last period? Could a second person rebuild it from the same inputs?
Finance teams answer those questions every quarter about revenue, accruals, and cash. That doesn't make the controller an emissions engineer. Operations understands equipment and consumption, sustainability professionals understand emissions methods, procurement holds supplier relationships and contract evidence, technology manages systems and access, and legal assesses obligations and disclosure language. I'd argue finance is best placed to connect them through one reporting process, because it already runs the review habits that disclosed numbers require.
I'd assign an accountable executive sponsor and a named process owner, with explicit duties to prepare, review, and approve each material dataset, and a different person reviewing each figure. A committee whose members can all request information but none can settle missing data leaves the reporting team exposed at the deadline.
Finance has done this before. Thomson Reuters, in COSO Publishes Guidance for Internal Control Over Sustainability Reporting, explains that Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires public companies to maintain and evaluate internal controls over financial reporting. In 2023, the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) applied the 17 principles of its control framework to sustainability reporting as supplemental guidance, which the CARB guidance doesn't call for. Jeffrey Thomson, who led the Institute of Management Accountants until March 2023, said an end-to-end data governance plan with clear owners is critical if sustainability information is to be decision-useful.
Build the Evidence Behind the Number
The CARB guidance shows how much judgment sits inside a single figure. For Scope 2, it notes that filers commonly draw emission factors from eGRID, a database maintained by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and described on its Emissions & Generation Resource Integrated Database (eGRID) page. The agency's latest official release covers 2023 data, and the 2024 edition hasn't come out on the usual timeline. Filers may use the 2023 release, the 2024 dataset published by the Cornerstone Sustainability Data Initiative, or another credible source, and CARB encourages them to name what they used. The source matters because different factors can produce different Scope 2 figures from the same electricity use. CARB also encourages filers to describe methodologies, data sources, organizational boundaries, and assumptions. Accountants will recognize the pattern. Choosing an emission factor resembles choosing an estimation method, and listing assumptions does the work of a footnote. None of it is exotic. It needs an owner.
The World Resources Institute and the World Business Council for Sustainable Development set the common frame in The Greenhouse Gas Protocol: A Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard (Revised Edition). Its transparency principle calls for a clear audit trail, with enough documentation that a third party could reach the same results from the same source data. The standard aims to produce a verifiable inventory but doesn't say how verification should be conducted. It dates to 2004, and the Greenhouse Gas Protocol is revising it, with a final third edition expected by the end of 2027 according to its Corporate Standard Revisions: Phase 1 Progress Update, December 2025, so confirm the current edition before you rely on it.
Management can turn that principle into a test. Pick one material reported figure and follow it backward through the calculation, the emission factor, the activity record, and the source document. Someone who didn't prepare it should be able to follow the same path.
An electricity invoice shows the work. Finance can reconcile utility accounts to the facilities register and check expense records for accounts missing from the inventory. The calculation still needs consumption units, the relevant period, an appropriate emission factor, and a documented treatment of leased premises. Dollars paid can't stand in for kilowatt-hours consumed.
Boundaries need the same care. An acquisition, a divestiture, or a change in operating control can alter what belongs in the inventory. Setting an organizational boundary resembles a consolidation decision, but the emissions boundary can call for judgments that differ from financial consolidation, and two functions shouldn't present incompatible versions of one business. Estimates need an owner as well. When a meter reading is missing, the record should identify the method, its basis, the reviewer, and what happens when better information arrives. Recording uncertainty honestly serves readers better than an unsupported number with several decimal places.
Controls Must Work Between Reporting Dates
COSO Chair Lucia Wind said in 2023, in the release COSO Releases New “Achieving Effective Internal Control Over Sustainability Reporting” (ICSR) Supplemental Guidance, that sustainable business reporting is still subject to evolution and innovation, so "it will be a process of continuous improvement including building internal capacity and relevant assurance." That matters because reporting capability develops through recurring work. An annual scramble leaves little room to find weaknesses before they become filing problems.
A proportionate process can start with a monthly or quarterly review of the largest emissions sources. Managers can look at missing records, unusual movements, changes in calculation methods, and overdue approvals, and can run each figure through the same review calendar as other disclosed numbers, with a comparison to the prior period and an explanation of changes. Smaller sources may justify less frequent review when the choice reflects the reporting risk.
Corrections need a path too. Utility invoices can be revised, meter readings corrected, and emission factor datasets updated after a figure is filed. Finance already has a process for numbers that change after the fact. Emissions figures need a version of it, with access controls and version histories, clear approval for any factor change, and a named person who decides when a change is material and how it gets disclosed.
Assurance Tests What Management Has Built
White & Case reports that SB 253 calls for limited assurance on Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions beginning in 2026 and reasonable assurance beginning in 2030. For this first cycle, CARB will accept reports with or without assurance, and it is still writing the rules for 2027 and beyond, assurance requirements included. A reasonable assurance engagement can stand in for a limited one, and Greenberg Traurig describes reasonable assurance as generally comparable to the standard used for financial-statement audits. Neither level guarantees accuracy.
Independent assurance adds scrutiny, but management stays responsible for producing the information. In August 2023, as the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) opened consultation on a proposed sustainability assurance standard, its Chair Tom Seidenstein said in IAASB Launches Public Consultation on Landmark Proposed Global Sustainability Assurance Standard, "Corporate reporting, whether financial or sustainability focused, is more trusted when it receives external and independent assurance based upon globally accepted standards independently developed in the public interest." The IAASB issued that standard, International Standard on Sustainability Assurance (ISSA) 5000, in November 2024. The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA), in An introduction to International Standard on Sustainability Assurance 5000 – part 1, says it applies to periods starting on or after December 15, 2026 in most jurisdictions.
The practitioner's work under that standard starts with the control environment. ACCA says assurance practitioners obtain an understanding of the entity's internal controls for the sustainability information, and it lists internal control weaknesses and reliance on third-party data among the early risks. A provider can examine evidence and challenge judgments. It can't create reliable records the company never kept. Data that lives in one person's spreadsheet struggles on both counts.
Morgan Lewis advises companies that rely on first-year discretion to document their good-faith compliance efforts, and a cycle without an assurance requirement is a good time to learn what an assurance provider would find.
How a Mature Finance Function Takes This On
Finance maturity shows in how a function absorbs a new class of disclosed data. A team with a close calendar, reconciliations, and sign-off already owns most of the machinery. The job is to extend it to emissions figures.
Scope 3 will test those habits further, since it enters in 2027. CDP, a global non-profit that runs an environmental disclosure system, found in its CDP Technical Note: Relevance of Scope 3 Categories by Sector that Scope 3 averaged 75% of combined Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions in its sample of 2021 responses from high-impact sectors. The share varies widely, and Scope 1 and 2 dominate in sectors such as cement and steel. A CDP and Boston Consulting Group release, Corporates’ supply chain scope 3 emissions are 26 times higher than their operational emissions, reports that companies disclosing to CDP put their 2023 supply chain Scope 3 emissions at an average of 26 times their Scope 1 and 2 emissions. Finance already manages vendor contracts, pricing, and risk reviews. Adding data-sharing terms to supplier agreements can make procurement a source of governed data, where a company controls less and has to document more. The same discipline helps smaller suppliers answer customer information requests, which aren't statutory filings, with data they can support.
For an international group, a common data foundation can serve several reporting needs while keeping each framework's adjustments. The IFRS Foundation says on Connecting IFRS Accounting and IFRS Sustainability that its accounting and sustainability standards are intended to work well together but need not be applied together, so assumptions should reconcile across reporting processes, with differences explained.
Emissions reporting becomes a finance function when the organization accepts responsibility for the reliability of what it reports. If a regulator asked how your Scope 2 figure was built, who in your company could answer without first asking around? After the November filing, ask the process owner to show one material figure from source record to final approval, and use the gaps to set priorities for the next cycle.
This article offers general business commentary about California's SB 253 and related developments as reported in public sources. It isn't legal, regulatory, accounting, or assurance advice. Applicability, requirements, and litigation status can change, and obligations depend on each company's facts. Obtain advice from qualified professionals for your circumstances.
When New Reporting Duties Reach Your Finance Team
Aspirations Consulting Group works with executives and other leaders at the moments when growth, transition, or performance pressure exposes gaps in data, controls, and finance capability, including the moment a new reporting duty makes those gaps visible to outsiders. The firm helps across the intersecting challenges those moments create, from governance to finance to operations, and you can see how we work with leadership teams at these inflection points.
Weekday Insights for Leaders Who Answer for the Numbers
Request a complimentary subscription to ACG Strategic Insights™ for practical perspectives on leadership, business, finance, and the decisions shaping organizational performance every weekday. The publication reaches more than 10 million executives and other leaders worldwide.
Thanks for reading!
~ Jerry Justice
Living to Serve, Serving to Lead™




Comments