A Growing Business With Weak EBITDA Quality Is Worth Less Than It Looks

A growth target can be met while the business behind it becomes harder to fund. Revenue rises, adjusted earnings improve, and the next budget assumes both gains will continue. Meanwhile customers take longer to pay, discounts become permanent, and expenses keep disappearing into adjustments.
That matters as calendar-year businesses set 2027 targets. December and January approvals turn assumptions into hiring commitments, borrowing needs and performance incentives, and boards and lenders tend to reward a confident growth plan during that window. I want the quality of the earnings settled before those commitments become hard to reverse.
EBITDA means earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization. It offers a useful view of operating performance, but it leaves out several demands on cash. EBITDA quality is the share of reported earnings that turns into cash, repeats from year to year and survives an outsider's review. A growing number deserves confidence only when its underlying economics deserve it.
Where Weak EBITDA Quality Hides in a Growing Business
Growth can raise EBITDA in ways that never raise value. Four patterns show up most often, and none is improper on its face. The question is whether leaders approved the full cost and can show the return.
Discounts buy volume. Fixed costs spread across more units, so EBITDA can rise even as each sale contributes less. Customers won on price can leave on price.
Longer payment terms win customers faster. The sale lands in revenue and EBITDA this quarter, and the cash arrives later. Until it does, your business funds its customers.
Capitalized spending moves a cost off the income statement and onto the balance sheet. Current EBITDA rises, and the cash still leaves. Accounting frameworks differ on what may be capitalized, so confirm the treatment with your finance team and auditors before you count on any gain.
Add-backs labeled one-time complete the set. A restructuring charge or a system replacement can be genuine. When a different exceptional cost appears every year, removing all of them can hide the expense of running and renewing the organization.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission staff makes the same point in Non-GAAP Financial Measures. It warns that a measure excluding "normal, recurring, cash operating expenses necessary to operate a registrant’s business" can mislead, and it treats an operating expense that occurs repeatedly, even at irregular intervals, as recurring. That guidance covers public-company reporting in the United States. Its question works for any private company too. Will some version of this expense remain necessary?
What the Evidence Says About Adjusted EBITDA
S&P Global Ratings has tested the distance between management projections and later results for years. In Why Is EBITDA addback analysis critical for investors?, a September 2026 edition of its CreditWeek series, the agency draws on its eighth annual add-back study. Add-backs average approximately 30% of management-adjusted EBITDA at deal inception across the 2015 to 2024 span, and historically 92% of companies missed their first-year earnings forecasts. S&P says its ratings rest on its own independent projections, and it puts the gap plainly. "There's often a vast difference between management projections and our own projections."
The agency's April 2025 report, EBITDA Addback Levels Remain High Despite Some Easing, shows the direction. Add-backs peaked at 32% of management-projected EBITDA for deals originated in 2021 and fell to 26% for 2023. Those percentages describe different groups of deals, not changes inside one company, and the denominator already includes the adjustments.
Read the scope carefully. These studies cover U.S. speculative-grade issuers, those rated BB+ or below, in large mergers and buyouts. A mid-market operating company in any country is not that sample. S&P notes that other factors, such as growth that did not materialize, may explain part of the gap between projected and reported earnings, and it attributes part of the latest debt misses to higher interest rates. The findings do not show that every miss came from an unjustified adjustment. Treat the pattern as a signal for your own business, not a benchmark.
Craig R. Everett, executive director of the Private Capital Markets Project at Pepperdine Graziadio Business School, reports a related pattern from the valuation side. In his 2025 Private Capital Markets Report, recast, or adjusted, EBITDA multiples led among the 68 investment bankers surveyed, used by 74% of them. Private equity respondents weighted recast EBITDA at 38% on average among multiple-based methods, and business appraisers weighted it at 45%. Pepperdine is a U.S. business school, so read these as U.S. figures and check practice in your own market.
Those figures matter for a simple reason. When valuers apply a multiple to the adjusted number, every dollar of add-back gets multiplied. A lender, buyer or director who rejects the add-back removes the dollar and the multiple attached to it. Your valuation falls by more than the adjustment.
Three Tests of Whether Growth Converts
You do not need a deal to run these. Your finance team can build all three from numbers you already have, and each works as a diagnostic, not a pass mark.
Start with EBITDA to operating cash flow. Divide trailing-12-month cash flow from operating activities by EBITDA before discretionary add-backs. Keep the definition consistent, compare several periods and reconcile the difference. If management also tracks conversion against adjusted EBITDA, show that denominator separately. Interest, taxes, working capital movements and seasonality all affect the result, so watch the direction more than the level. That direction is the clearest early read on EBITDA quality.
A sound growth plan may deliberately consume cash through inventory and receivables before collections arrive. The test is whether the funding need was forecast, financed and followed by the expected collections. Operating cash flow also precedes capital spending, so review it beside what you invest in equipment, software and development. Grant Thornton Netherlands makes the core point in EBITDA vs. Cash Flow: The hidden costs that can erode value. EBITDA is not cash flow, a healthy business should generate strong free cash flow relative to EBITDA, and stretching payables or speeding receivables can flatter short-term cash.
Next, measure the add-back share of EBITDA. Divide total add-backs by adjusted EBITDA and show the unadjusted figure beside it, with each adjustment named. S&P reports the share against management-adjusted EBITDA, so the comparison is close but not exact, and dividing by the unadjusted figure gives a larger percentage. Label which one you use. For each item, establish why it qualifies, whether cash has been spent, when the cost ends and what evidence supports any projected saving. Anything that has returned in 2 or more consecutive years deserves treatment as an operating cost. An expected saving needs an owner, a delivery date and a later comparison with actual results. The approximately 30% average from S&P is a reference point. An adjustment improves understanding when it isolates a genuinely unusual event, and its credibility weakens when the promised benefit keeps moving into the next forecast.
Finish with revenue quality by customer. Review customers, and groups won in the same period, by net price after discounts and rebates, contribution after direct service costs, payment behavior, retention and concentration. Rank them by the cash they earn after discounts, terms and the cost of serving them, not by revenue. Grant Thornton lists high customer concentration and volume-based discounts among the risks behind strong EBITDA. A thin-margin account can still be a sound choice when it brings repeat business or access to a valuable market. Put that reasoning in the plan and test it later. Keep directly attributable costs apart from shared costs, because arbitrary overhead allocations can make a healthy account appear unprofitable.
What to Put Beside the Growth Target
Put the quality measures beside the growth target in the 2027 board package. Show the target, earnings before add-backs, adjusted EBITDA, operating cash flow and required reinvestment, with the customer assumptions and the adjustment schedule that explain them. Use the debt agreement's required definition for covenant reporting. Beside it, give directors and lenders a consistent management view of earnings and cash. A contractual measure serves a particular purpose and cannot answer every question about operating health.
Test the plan with slower collections, less discount recovery and delayed savings. Identify which commitments would change and who would decide. Where a test shows a weak result, say so and explain it. A weak result you have explained costs less credibility than one a lender finds on their own.
Aswath Damodaran, professor of finance at the NYU Stern School of Business, states the principle in his valuation course slides, Value Enhancement and the Expected Value of Control: Back to Basics. "Growth, by itself, does not create value." His analysis ties value to investments that earn more than their cost of capital. Better EBITDA is useful evidence, and the return on the resources needed to produce it completes the judgment.
EBITDA quality matters because a business that needs less cash to sustain dependable earnings has more freedom to invest, repay debt and absorb setbacks. That freedom matters long before anyone considers a sale. If a stranger rebuilt your EBITDA from the cash records, would they land close to your number? Before you approve the next growth target, require the plan to show what the business must spend, concede and collect to earn it.
When Growth Plans Need Numbers That Hold Up
Growth puts financial, operational and leadership demands on an organization at the same time, and a gap between reported earnings and real performance often surfaces first in a board or lender review. Aspirations Consulting Group works with executives of mid-market and Fortune 1000 companies at those inflection points, connecting financial strategy, reporting and growth planning so the plan and the numbers support each other.
Weekday Insight for Your 2027 Planning
Each weekday, ACG Strategic Insights™ brings more than 10 million current and aspiring executives worldwide practical thinking on strategy, finance, technology and leadership, and you can request a complimentary subscription to receive it.
Thanks for reading!
~ Jerry Justice
Living to Serve, Serving to Lead™




Comments