top of page

ACG Strategic Insights

Strategic Intelligence That Drives Results

About the Author​

​

Jerry Justice is Founder and CEO of Aspirations Consulting Group, bringing three decades of global entrepreneurial and corporate executive experience to ACG's consulting work with organizations across five industries facing growth, transition, and operational change. Through ACG Strategic Insights™, he reaches more than 10 million executives and aspiring leaders worldwide each weekday. He writes and speaks internationally on leadership, business strategy, and organizational performance, guided by his personal philosophy, Living to Serve, Serving to Lead™.

Some Leaders Distrust Their Data and Others Over-Trust Their Dashboards

Writer: Jerry Justice
Jerry Justice
3 days ago
6 min read
Source records and a notebook sit in front of a laptop displaying business charts.
A clear display still needs a clear explanation.

Budget season rewards the leader who arrives with numbers. The dashboards behind a 2027 plan get refreshed, reviewed, and pasted into slides. Revenue run rate. Customer count. Cost per unit. Pipeline coverage. Each one can shape headcount and capital for a year or more.


That's a lot of weight on figures that many leaders question only occasionally. Organizations on a calendar fiscal year are setting 2027 budgets now, and every planning calendar has its own version of this moment. The question isn't whether you use dashboards. It's whether you know why you believe what they say.


Trust in data fails in two directions. Some leaders discount good numbers and decide on instinct. Others trust their dashboards without asking where a figure came from. Both are failures of trust, and neither is a problem of data quality. You can start with clean data and still get both wrong.


What One Survey Shows About How Leaders Trust Their Dashboards


TheyDo sells customer journey management software. It had Sapio Research survey 500 senior decision-makers in the United States, the United Kingdom, and the Netherlands, and it released the results on December 11, 2024 in Data, decisions, and doubt: a 2025 leadership perspective. The report argues for journey management tools over static dashboards, so the company has a commercial interest in the findings. The sample covers only those countries and says little about leaders elsewhere. It's also nearly 2 years old.


Within those limits, the numbers are worth reading. Of the leaders surveyed, 77% said they only sometimes or rarely question the data they rely on. Yet 67% worried that over-reliance on static dashboards risks missing critical opportunities. And only 45% of business data was fully used in decisions.


The first two figures sit uneasily together. Most leaders say they question their data only occasionally, and most also worry about depending on it. The 45% figure points the other way. If more than half of business data isn't fully used in decisions, some of it may be set aside. The survey doesn't say why. Time is one reason, since 34% of leaders said they lack the time to analyze the data they receive effectively. Doubt may be another, but the survey doesn't test it. Over-trust and under-trust can sit side by side in the same organization, though the survey doesn't test that either.


Two Errors With One Root


The first error is easy to spot once you name it. Leaders trust their dashboards because the numbers arrive in a clean chart and a familiar layout, and they look official. Nobody asks who defined the figure, when it last refreshed, or what was left out. The dashboard borrows authority from its design.


The second error is quieter. A leader who has been misled by one bad report may start treating every report as suspect. An experienced leader may trust judgment built on past conditions over a figure that describes the present. Sometimes the instinct is right. Often it's a conclusion reached before anyone checked.


Proceeding on imperfect data isn't the error. In PwC's 2026 Digital Trends in Operations Survey, 84% of the 767 operations and supply chain leaders at US companies said they have become comfortable making decisions even when data isn't perfect. That can be sound judgment. The survey covers one function in one country, and PwC also advises on these questions, so read it as a signal, not a verdict. The risk is proceeding without knowing what is imperfect.


Both errors share a root. Most organizations never decide in advance what counts as good enough evidence for a decision. Deloitte researchers made the point in AI and the future of human decision-making, published in March 2026, writing that "Most organizations still treat decisions as by-products of meetings and dashboards" instead of designing them on purpose. Deloitte also advises organizations on decision-making, so it has its own interest in the subject.


Research on how confidence builds helps explain why neither error corrects itself. Peter J. Boyle, a professor at Central Washington University, and his coauthor Pete Nye of the University of Washington Bothell published Information distortion as a source of overconfidence in managerial decisions in Judgment and Decision Making in February 2026. They gave 142 MBA students with prior business experience, in programs at US universities, a hypothetical advertising decision, with information arriving in sequence and balanced between launching and not launching. As a preference formed, participants read new information as favoring it, and their confidence rose beyond what the information justified. The authors wrote, "The process went undetected by decision makers." Among the 53 participants who rated their own bias, those ratings did not track how much their confidence grew.


The task carried no real stakes and did not involve dashboards. Applied here, the mechanism is still useful. A leader who has leaned toward a plan can read a supportive figure as proof and a contrary one as an error, and neither reading checks the number.


Four Questions to Ask Before You Act on Any Number


You don't need a data team to test a number. You need four questions, asked out loud, in the room where the decision gets made.


Where did it come from? Ask for the system of record and the date of the last refresh. Find out whether anyone adjusted the figure by hand between the source and the screen. A number with a clear path back to its origin earns trust quickly. One nobody can trace should slow the decision down.


What exactly does it count? Labels such as customer, active user, bookings, and margin can mean different things in different functions, and accounting rules differ by jurisdiction. Ask for the written definition, including what's excluded and the period covered. If no definition exists, you've learned something before spending a dollar.


Who owns it? Every number that drives a budget needs one named person who can explain why it moved. A team can't answer a follow-up question, and neither can a dashboard. Ownership also tells you who to call when the figure looks wrong, so the question doesn't turn into an argument about whose data is right.


What would change the answer? Decide before you look. State which result would lead you to choose differently and how much evidence you'd need. The reason to do it first is the confidence finding above, since confidence grew as evidence arrived and participants didn't notice. The same Deloitte article urges organizations to define what counts as fit-for-decision evidence, and how it will be used, before AI enters the process. The same discipline applies when AI isn't involved. If nothing could change your mind, you're deciding on instinct. That's sometimes the right call, but name it as one. If a figure could change your mind, be ready to accept it when it arrives.


Hold both kinds of numbers to the same four questions, the ones that confirm what you expected and the ones that don't. Questioning only the disappointing figures protects a conclusion and tests nothing.


Put the Questions to Work in Your 2027 Plan


Most plans rest on a handful of figures. Pick the ones that carry the most weight and run the questions on those first. Write the answers beside each number in the planning deck, so the next reader inherits the reasoning along with the figure. Where the answers are thin, label the number as an assumption and say who will confirm it, and when.


None of this guarantees a better decision. A number with a clear source, definition, and owner can still be the wrong number to decide on, and judgment still has to weigh what data can't capture. The goal is narrower. You want to know why you trust a figure, or why you don't, before the budget locks.


Build Ownership Into the Numbers Behind Your Biggest Decisions


Aspirations Consulting Group works with executives and other leaders at the points where a plan has to hold up under pressure, such as a growth push, a leadership transition, or a year when results fall short of the budget. We help leadership teams settle who owns the numbers behind their largest decisions, how those decisions get made, and how finance, operations, and technology stay in step. If that sounds like your 2027, see how we work with leadership teams.


Keep the Questions Coming After Budget Season


Request a complimentary subscription to ACG Strategic Insights™, the weekday publication that reaches more than 10 million executives and other leaders worldwide with practical ideas on strategy, decisions, and leadership.


Thanks for reading!


~ Jerry Justice

Living to Serve, Serving to Lead™

Comments


ACG Diagnostic Series™

​Know exactly where you stand.

 

Two suites. Four instruments. Rigorous assessments of your leadership and financial judgment — built for serious leaders.

 

Leadership Suite
 

ACG Leadership Diagnostic™ 
ACG Leadership Assessment™ 

​​

​Financial Edge Suite
 

ACG Financial Edge Diagnostic™ 
ACG Financial Edge Assessment™

©2026 ASPIRATIONS CONSULTING GROUP, LLC™.  ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

bottom of page