top of page

ACG Strategic Insights

Strategic Intelligence That Drives Results

About the Author​

​

Jerry Justice is Founder and CEO of Aspirations Consulting Group, bringing three decades of global entrepreneurial and corporate executive experience to ACG's consulting work with organizations across five industries facing growth, transition, and operational change. Through ACG Strategic Insights™, he reaches more than 10 million executives and aspiring leaders worldwide each weekday. He writes and speaks internationally on leadership, business strategy, and organizational performance, guided by his personal philosophy, Living to Serve, Serving to Lead™.

CEO Tenure Swings While Strategy Horizons Hold

Writer: Jerry Justice
Jerry Justice
12 hours ago
6 min read
Strategic roadmap and hourglass representing multiyear strategy execution under shorter CEO tenures.
Enduring enterprise value requires multiyear strategic plans anchored in institutional governance rather than a single executive's tenure.

A multiyear plan can be approved in an afternoon. Building the capabilities behind it takes years, and the leader who won the approval may be gone before the work pays off.


Your plan has to survive that. No tracker can tell you how long CEO tenure will run for your CEO, and the data swings hard enough that nobody should bet on it. A strategy that depends on its sponsor staying depends on luck.


What the CEO Tenure Numbers Say


Spencer Stuart tracks leadership changes across the S&P 1500. Its report, 2025 S&P 1500 CEO Transitions: Behind the CEO Moment, puts the average tenure of departing CEOs at 8.5 years in 2025. That is down from a peak of 10.3 years in 2021 and the lowest level since 2019. Of the CEOs who left, 37% went within their first 5 years. In the S&P 500, 45% were gone by the 5-year mark.


The report also draws on the firm’s life-cycle research, which finds the most successful CEOs pull away from lower performers in years 3 to 5. Boards today are more willing to act when they see warning signs, so that window matters.


The pattern was global through 2025. Russell Reynolds Associates reports in Shorter Runways, Higher Stakes: What Today’s CEO Turnover Means For Boards and Succession that outgoing CEOs across the global stock indices it tracks averaged 7.1 years in 2025, down from 8.3 years in 2021. The share of CEOs leaving within 30 to 36 months rose 79% in a single year. Laura Sanderson, EMEAI co-lead at the firm, says the first couple of years used to go to clarifying the mandate and building alignment. “That grace period has been severely compressed.”


Then 2026 arrived. In its memorandum Global CEO Turnover Index, the firm counted 101 departures in the first half of 2026, the lowest first-half total in its 9-year tracking period. Departing CEOs averaged 9.0 years, up from 6.6 years in the first half of 2025. In the FTSE 100, departing CEOs averaged 12.5 years, against a 9-year average of 7.7 years. The firm links the calmer half to rising markets and boards that favor continuity. Small indices swing easily. The FTSE 100 recorded only 6 CEO appointments in the half, up from 3 a year earlier, so one or two long-serving exits can move its average a long way.


Read together, the numbers say CEO tenure swings. It compressed through 2025 and rebounded in 2026. Neither direction gives you a number to plan around, and a quiet half-year does not change how boards judge. The leader who arrived this year still faces the year 3 to 5 window.


Strategy Horizons Hold


Nothing in this data has shortened what companies are trying to do. PwC surveyed 4,454 CEOs across 95 countries and territories for Leading through Uncertainty in the Age of AI, its 29th Global CEO Survey. Leaders are pressing ahead with multiyear reinvention. More than half, 56%, report neither higher revenue nor lower costs from AI in the past 12 months, and they keep investing. More than 40% say their companies began competing in new sectors within the last 5 years.


Those are bets measured in years, not quarters.


The same survey shows where the leader’s attention goes. CEOs say they spend 47% of their time on issues with horizons under a year and 16% on horizons of 5 years or more. The longest commitments in the company get the thinnest slice of the leader’s time.


Three clocks run at once. The leader’s seat has averaged 7.1 to 9.0 years before its holder leaves, depending on the tracker and the period. The board’s judgment window opens around year 3. The commitment pays off on its own schedule, often beyond both.


When the clocks fall out of step, two problems follow. A leader who expects early judgment may favor work that shows results within a few quarters and defer investments that pay off later. The pressure is real, since Russell Reynolds Associates describes leadership success as increasingly defined by rapid, visible results. The second problem arrives with the next leader.


Good Strategy Fails at the Handoff


Research on succession points to a habit that has little to do with merit. Professor Thomas Hutzschenreuter of the Technical University of Munich and two co-authors examined what successor CEOs choose to divest in Seeking distinctiveness through divestments: CEO succession and the effect of demographic similarity on the divestment of predecessor’s investments, published in Managerial and Decision Economics. When a successor resembles the predecessor in demographic terms, the successor is more likely to divest the units the predecessor invested in. The driver is a need to look distinct. It is not a verdict on the investment.


A plan that carries one executive’s name invites that reaction. The person inheriting it is also usually new to the job, since Spencer Stuart found that 84% of the S&P 1500 CEOs named in 2025 were first-time CEOs.


Richard Rumelt of the UCLA Anderson School of Management writes in The perils of bad strategy, published in McKinsey Quarterly, that strategy is “coherent action backed by an argument.” The argument is the part that gets lost. If the challenge was never defined, Rumelt notes, you cannot assess the strategy, and then you cannot reject a bad one or improve a good one. A successor who inherits the actions without the argument has nothing to test them against. Starting over becomes the easy move.


Build the Plan So It Outlasts the Leader


You cannot control how long your CEO stays. You can control whether the plan needs them to stay.


  • Keep a living strategic charter. For each major commitment, record the problem it addresses, the evidence behind the choice, the options you rejected, and the assumptions most likely to fail. Update it when the evidence changes, so a reader can see what was believed at approval and what has been learned since.

  • Tie multiyear initiatives to board-approved funding checkpoints. When the board, CEO, and CFO jointly govern funding tranches and return expectations, an initiative carries legitimacy that survives a change at the top.

  • Separate enduring commitments from a leader’s signature initiatives. Core platform work, balance-sheet strength, and customer retention should not reset automatically after a transition. That also leaves a new CEO clear room to launch targeted ideas of their own.

  • Put early evidence inside year 3. For a capacity expansion, that means customer commitments, permitting progress, and construction readiness before the facility earns revenue. Agree up front on the difference between a delayed benefit and a broken assumption.

  • Agree on reasons to reconsider before pressure arrives. Name the evidence that would support continued funding, a change in scope, or a stop. Judge the choice on what remains to be spent, not on what is already spent.

  • Make continuity an ownership question. The board, or the relevant owners, should preserve the strategic reasoning while holding management accountable for results. In a group, local approvals, workforce arrangements, and customer conditions are part of that reasoning, and a statement of support at headquarters cannot replace them.


None of this freezes strategy. A new CEO should change a plan when the evidence moves. The goal is to make that a decision with reasons, not a reflex.


Before your next strategy review, pick one commitment whose benefits extend several years. Ask the people who execute and oversee it to explain its rationale without leaning on the CEO. Have them name the next funding decision and the evidence that would change their recommendation. If their answers differ, reconcile them and record the judgment.


Plan as if CEO tenure will end before the plan does. Then ask which of your commitments would survive a new CEO’s first review. If the honest answer is none, the plan belongs to a person and not to the company.


Strategy That Survives the Next Handoff


When growth, leadership change, or performance pressure exposes gaps between a company’s ambitions and its ability to deliver, Aspirations Consulting Group helps executives bring strategy, people, operations, and financial choices into a coherent plan. We build planning and continuity that rest on evidence and shared ownership, so the work carries on whoever holds the seat. See how we approach strategic planning and continuity. Clarity. Strategy. Impact.™


Planning Ideas Delivered Every Weekday


Join more than 10 million executives and other leaders worldwide who receive ACG Strategic Insights™ every weekday, and request a complimentary subscription for practical thinking on leadership, strategy, finance, and the decisions shaping your organization.


Thanks for reading!


~ Jerry Justice

Living to Serve, Serving to Lead™

Comments


ACG Diagnostic Series™

​Know exactly where you stand.

 

Two suites. Four instruments. Rigorous assessments of your leadership and financial judgment — built for serious leaders.

 

Leadership Suite
 

ACG Leadership Diagnostic™ 
ACG Leadership Assessment™ 

​​

​Financial Edge Suite
 

ACG Financial Edge Diagnostic™ 
ACG Financial Edge Assessment™

©2026 ASPIRATIONS CONSULTING GROUP, LLC™.  ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

bottom of page